Quantcast
CAPO
pro cycling news
What's cool in pro cycling
 
 
 
 
 
Wrench Science
 
PEZ-Test: Colnago’s Extreme Power
Wednesday, November 14, 2007  12:43:36 PM PT

by Charles Manantan

  Not many brands create the automatic salivation that Colnago do. Sure there are lots of great bikes and dare I say that no single stock bicycle maker is the right choice for everyone… But you’ll not find a long list of companies or men that would claim to be better recognized and have a better track record of recent and past success than Ernesto Colnago and Colnago Bicycles…

Not many bike geek/would be writers wouldn’t hop on a plane at the invitation to have Ernesto Colnago personally measure you up for a bike. And as I fit the geek thing pretty well, I was happy to grab a flight out to Veltec Sport’s new distribution facility and have a look at their latest line up and have an audience with the pope of pedaling…



And as my fluent Italian is limited to ordering beer and making a fool of myself with women (I’m multilingual there…) it was a pleasure to also have Alex Colnago on hand as he’s both a breeze in English and is also an exceptional cycling resource on his own.



I could sit for hours listening to the recap of conversations like the one Ernesto had to have with the Mapei team to convince them that their new “Fabric bike” would be able to at least survive Paris Roubaix. It goes without saying that the conversation went a lot smoother with the team after “Fabric” rolled into the Velodrome with a 1,2,3 finish for the C-40…

And it was pretty much at that point that carbon fiber became more than simply an acceptable risk…

But after a period that was far too short talking about cycling history for Colnago that is anything but… We got down to the table of goodies that kept pulling at my attention.



Easily my favorite look of the bunch was the Italian TriColore themed Extreme Power and it was that bike that I snatched up and ran out with, but as I risked getting my but kicked by a girl for hogging the frame, I settled for simple snapping a picture and sadly handed it back.



From there it was over to having Ernesto size up a few lucky people.

But rather than the typical fitting you get from professional coaches, this one was rather less formal or scientific.

A quick check of height…



An arm length and an inseam check and a couple of other measurements had me wondering “is that really all you need?” to which the very confident reply with a smile was “with your flexibility, I decided on your size without measuring, but I wanted you to have something to take with you…”

There was also a case where it seemed like making one custom fit body was better than making a 23rd stock size for Colnago…



But in actuality it was just some tight (and deceptively strong) legs on Uber-Journo Bruce Hildenbrand that needed some stretching. And after hearing Ernesto speak and watch him work a bit, it was no surprise at all to see him step in. His image as a the Capo of cycling wasn’t earned because his hands have ever been afraid of work.

All said and done, I wound up with completed, signed and autographed personal fit sheet mailed to me shortly afterward.



But then it was the big box that came a short while later that contained the story subject for today... And it wound up being the exact frame that I had tried hopelessly to sneak out of the meeting, fit in my backpack, under my shirt and covered with a tablecloth…

The new Extreme Power.


the thumbnail at the top of the story has a BIG picture…

I knew it was on the way, and had time to scan their web site 1043 times looking at the catalogue shot as well as scrolling through my own pictures. But despite the mental build-up, the looks of this bicycle simply exceeded my own self-hyped expectations. Yeah, sure that’s a personal thing. Looks always are, and this may simply not be your thing. But I can say that the first couple of rides had guys in the group drifting aimlessly toward me and it wasn’t because I looked good in my Pez shorts (at least I hope not…).

And though Ernesto made very little fuss in fitting me up, he had something in common with the tailor I use. After decades at the top of the business both men simply know how to mate “fabric” to bodies… (and you're shy a couple thousand dollars every time you visit them both as well...)

The frame and stem length were a dead on match to the extremely detailed medical fit I’ve had from three different, and well known, bike fitters…

Out The Box

The Frame itself is fairly classic in design, no huge wiggles or extreme bulges. But Colnago continue to get more visual “bang” with less actual paint than just about anyone…

All that aside, it’s what few people will ever see that set the Extreme Power apart from it’s also beautiful brother the C-50. It’s Colnago’s continued partnership with a carbon supplier for a team that gets more visual “bang” from one color that just about anyone else does with a full pallet…



Something that Colnago have reasonable access to is the same tech going into Formula One. While other bicycle manufacturers claim to have ties with the same producers of carbon for the slightly faster sport, Colnago have incorporated some of the tech in the new Extreme Power. And in typical Colnago fashion, they apply the technology without effecting traditional lines of the bicycle by reinforcing the inside of the tubes…



Note the raised section fairly easy to see above in yellow.

Colnago put additional material where it will perform the function in both short addition…



And longer reinforcement…



It’s this improved stiffness that shows itself in the form of resisting better side stress that raises the game for the Extreme Power to a higher level for cyclists that want that extra stiffness over the C-50.

Colnago leave the tubes exterior as a rounded shape that is also conical growing, as lots of performance bikes do, from the head tube down to the bottom bracket.




The BB looks quite a bit like the standard C50 and its C40 elders, A traditional lug with tubes inserted, and also with a machined Titanium insert to house the cranks.



All in all, the more traditional lines make for a modern classic that doesn’t rely on much gimmick to sell itself…



The rear end doesn’t do much in the way of special shapes either. It keeps the tried and tested wishbone design and fairly straight seat stay legs that ask for nothing more (than maybe a black set of brakes...)



But the chain stays do get a fair boost in volume, top to bottom in what Colnago call a “leaf” shape. And like some leafs there is a side reinforcing rib running the center that will help with side flex…



Up front, the Extreme gets the Star Carbon fork that also has a very slight bulge in the center of its straight, clubman, style blades. But the paint hides it very well and helps maintain the simple lines of the Extreme Power.




That’s The “Stuff”
But is the frame and kit together the right stuff?

Well yes and no.

I say (too often) that one of the things I try to do is have some sort of baseline for bike tests… It’s not pure science and my “buttometer” can require a few cracks at something, mixed in with some back to back riding of other bikes with the same base components in order to get a better feel. This was one time where baseline equipment was absolutely a good thing.

Initially this bike came presented as such (sorry for a reposted picture, but it beats scrolling up…)



It was transformed however into what looks pretty similar to, but wound up being a substantial change for the better…



Kinda a “where’s Waldo” puzzle, but the answer is easy. Waldo’s in Florida at the American Classic factory…



“Waldo” was also to a lesser extent hidden in this seat post and saddle, as it was a carbon veneer around alloy.



They got swapped out for a 3t “Less” post that weighed, well, less… It along with my own saddle put things a bit more right, lowering road vibes and the center of gravity at the same time.

I’ve often wondered if I was really doing any sort of good by trying to swap to familiar wheels and tires (same pressures) on test bikes, thinking I should simply do like a few other testers and spend half an article mugging for the camera rather than shooting closeups of the bike and then spend a while talking or chirping about a build kit that doesn’t suite me (in an attempt to find something insignificant to complain about so I sound “neutral”).

This was one time where it really made a difference.

I used American Classics Magnesium wheels along with Zipp tubies on every test bike this year. Most of the time I tell companies to send the bike without wheels, but this one came with Fulcrum Racing 1’s and I rode the bike as sent.

I came back after 3 rides on the same 90 minute test course that every bike gets thinking the Extreme is absolutely stiffer feeling than the 50… But I had a kinda uneasy feeling as I wanted to be blown away and really feel like I was delivering more stable / less flexy power. The problem was that I felt the more stable / less flexy part, but couldn’t bring my self to admit to feeling any faster. In fact, when I would do jumps and sprints or brief but steep climbs, I felt slower…

Honestly I wondered what was wrong with me, as I couldn’t get my head around a bike like this feeling worse than the 50 (and I have a 50 here for direct comparison… as well as a 40…).

So I slip on the Mag 300’s… And poof, the Extreme reminds me of my Catholic School girl friend’s “character” change after the bell rang and she hopped in the car on Friday (or well, any day really).

Absolutely ready for a bit of, er. Able to get me up the… eh, well, Begging to be… Um… One minute please.





OK right then.

The Extreme Power, with a wheel set that has adequate stiffness but whole lot less mass rotating at the rim, makes this a better attacking bike than its brother (another note that we ran the same Vredestein Fortezza Tricomp's that were on the Fulcrums and at same pressure). The little bit of extra stiffness really does show up… And rather than a noticeably rougher ride on the Extreme, the comfort level with the same wheels and tires and pressures is pretty comparable to the C50 on all but infrequent large bumps and harder hits. The soaking up of road buzz and clatter that you face on 99% of your ride is C series good.

And when I say it's comperable to the C50 in comfort in most conditions, that means it's very good. I would hate for anyone to come away thinking that either of these bikes is simply acceptable, as the C50 is one of the best all around bikes available.

In fact that’s where Colnago have a winner here. The Extreme Power, in my opinion (as someone who doesn’t need to market a bicycle…), should be called the “Enough Power”… Enough for big power guys, but not over cooked to the point where it robs a lot of comfort.

That’s typical Colnago as well… They’ve never been one to chase a statistic over ride quality… and that plays out oddly enough in a statistic.

This one.



When you’re invested in the ride, you make 22 sizes because fit at days end is critical to ride quality…

All that said, I am still a standard C-50 guy. Not because it’s a better bike, but because it’s a different bike, and for every guy like me (150 lbs and appreciative of smoothness and light weight) there is a bigger, stomper type guy wanting the added stability and stiffness that comes with the Extreme Power. I would be very happy with either, but they both have a lean toward a type of rider and both offer a massive range of fit…

Now in fairness to Fulcrum they make a slightly better wheel than their Mavic cousins the Ksyrium but I am not a sloppy guy that will notice that the American Classics do have more side flex. I am not a low power guy either, and simply notice the FAR snappier acceleration and better, quicker handling of the lighter American Classic and Zipps (even Zipps CSC training clinchers) more than I notice any better stiffness of the Fulcrum. This was a great example of how important wheels are to a bike. I would say that wheels are more important than most of us give them credit for…

So there it is…

Smoothness on par with the smoothest in most conditions and far better than several bikes built with a stiffness focus. Stiffness increased to the point where Petacchi, Zabel, Freire and a few of their flat land bodyguards chose it, and enough sizes to suite, well, more people than bike companies with fewer sizes can…

Handling is stable, not super fast / twitchy. There's more geometry available, but then Colnago will also Knock out custom geometry for those wanting to wait. This isn't sluggish, its neutral and won't have you messing around much holding a line.

The weight is @1100 grams (53) frame and while not an ultralight on the scale, the low and well placed center of gravity (of frame and, with good fit, the rider is centered as well) makes for a bike that feels lighter than its respectable stats.

Price is near the top end of anything in cycling, but then the Extreme Power’s price is relative to its earned place near the top of the food chain... Expect to kick out some place between 4 and 5,000 dollars for frame and fork.


One line description?
The C50 is among the best all round frames available and The Extreme Power is it's tougher stronger twin.


You can contact Veltec Sports for a dealer near you, and I would strongly suggest buying from an approved dealer rather than risking sending your money over the ocean…

Have Fun,

Charles Manantan



Thanks for looking. We’re happy to bring you lots of large pictures built into the story rather than making you click a bunch of extra pages and thumbnails. We would rather make things convenient and entertaining for you than artificially inflate our page view count to pump up advertising numbers…

Note: if you have other experiences with gear, or something to add, drop us a line. We don’t claim to know everything (we just imply it at times). Give us a pat on the back if you like the reviews or a slap in the head if you feel the need!

PezCycling News and the author ask that you contact the manufacturers before using any products we test here. Only the manufacturer can provide accurate and complete information on proper use and or installation of products as well as any conditional information or product limitations.

Send your comments to: manager@pezcyclingnews.com

Read More Cool PezCycling Stories
Colnago EPS
Colnago CLX: PEZ Giro Spec
PEZ Tests Colnago CLX
Colnago EPS
Toolbox: Pedaling Asymmetry
Colnago EPS
Toolbox: Bright Lights Big City


PEZ-A-PAL - Send this story to a friend GET PEZ'd: Try Our RSS Feed
Giro 2010 Up Close: The Hellacious Final Week
Friday, November 06, 2009  8:34:07 AM PT
  The first fourteen stages of the 2010 Giro d'Italia are going to be the standard, delicious Giro fare. The final final seven days are going to be the ...
More....

Grenoble'09: Marvellous Marvulli Tallies #5!
Thursday, November 05, 2009  11:51:37 AM PT
  Four nights down, two to go. The racing was hot in Grenoble, the sideshows, arguably, just as hot. Edmond Hood was on the scene, working hard, making ...
More....
PEZ Reviews: CRUD Fenders
  The dust has yet to settle from the storm of Interbike, but the rains have started here at PEZ HQ, and that means time to strap on that piece of rain ...
More....

Interbike 2009: Hidden Treasure, Good Deal, New Stuff
  From the show that just keeps on giving - another round of bit's... C-4 explodes, AX swings, EE in your BB, San Marco and Topolino...
More....

Interbike '09: The Hits Just Keep On Comin!
  Yes – it’s been a couple weeks since our last post, but we’re back and rollin' with more Interbike goodies, and the wait is worth it – Here’s what’s ...
More....

Interbike 2009: More to Score
  More from the shores of Treasure Island, this round brings a look at the latest from Look Cycles, chunks of hunks from Bonk Breaker, a ...
More....

Interbike 2009: Here We Go!
  So we're back from Interbike 2009. The hangover is very nearly gone, the feet are not close to normal, the back is still sore, but nothing itches ...
More....
Toolbox: Beginner’s Mind, Part 2
  Zen masters let go of ego; teenagers are in the middle of creating one. That makes it a good time to coach mental skills with teens, and also a good ...
More....

Toolbox: Priming the Engine
  Cyclocross season is steadily progressing from the early season of warm and dry race days to the downright miserable and ugly weather that define the ...
More....

Toolbox: Cutting Edge Nutrition Strategies
  As fall is settling upon the Northern Hemisphere many cyclists are looking forward to both the crux off their off-season and starting to plan for ...
More....

Toolbox: Italia Calling
  With Lombardia and the end-of-season emphasis on all things Italia, what better way to begin the off-season transition than enjoy some quality miles ...
More....
Giro d'Italia Tour of Italy
Giro Di PEZ: The Race Of The Lasts
Sunday, June 07, 2009  7:50:39 AM PT
  Post-Giro Roadside: This year I chased just three stages. I chose the three stages closest to home for me, in the centre of Italy, on the ...
More....

Giro Di PEZ: Ed And Dave Look Back
Friday, June 05, 2009  5:05:48 AM PT
  Post-Giro Roadside: I love Scotland; but there’s no Gazzetta in the morning, most of the coffee tastes like John Wayne brewed it beside the ...
More....

Giro di PEZ: Week 2 Outtakes!
Thursday, June 04, 2009  8:11:24 AM PT
  Post-Giro Roadside: Two weeks can be a long time, unless you’re chasing a Grand Tour. I flew over to cover the Giro’s second week, and ...
More....

Giro Di PEZ: Wonderful Week One!
Wednesday, June 03, 2009  3:39:58 AM PT
  Post-Giro Roadside: The Centenary Giro has only been over for a few days, but my personal trip to the Corsa Rosa ended back on Stage 5. With ...
More....
2009 Tour de France
Tour de Pez: Looking Back At A Tour Gone By
Friday, July 31, 2009  5:32:12 AM PT
  Roadside Recap: As we make our merry way through the rounds of the PEZ Looks Back, Ed is up for his retrospective on the Tour that was. As the ...
More....

Tour de Pez: ASO’s Marilyn Urtubia
Friday, July 31, 2009  4:49:37 AM PT
  Roadside Look Back: For the press core, one of the more familiar sights behind the scenes at this year’s Tour de France was the welcoming ...
More....

Tour de Pez: PGTSD
Wednesday, July 29, 2009  6:00:38 AM PT
  Roadside Wrap: That's Post Grand Tour Stress Disorder. The Champs Elysées stage of le Tour is the climax, the culmination of a near ...
More....

Tour de Pez: Gord Looks Back
Tuesday, July 28, 2009  6:25:33 AM PT
  Roadside Wrap: My second big adventure on the Tour, my second year behind the scenes riding the maddest, scariest, most thrilling ...
More....
 
PEZ Talk: Revolution's James Pope
  Amongst all the gloom and doom of sponsors pulling out disenchanted with doping scandals, and races folding, winter track racing does have its ...
More....

PEZ Talk: Six Day Up And Comers East And Carroll
  They may sound like a lounge singing duet, but there's no schmaltz to these guy's mission; they're trying to build a career playing to that most ...
More....

PEZ Talk: Milram's Luke Roberts
  The best team pursuit rider, ever? With national, world junior, Commonwealth, world senior and Olympic titles to his name, Aussie, Luke Roberts ...
More....

PEZ Talk: UK's Newest ProTour Rider, Tom Faiers
  Here at Pez we pride ourselves on being on the case of who's up and coming - but sometimes even Pez misses the boat. The first we heard of Tom Faiers ...
More....

PEZ-Clusive: His Name Is Clear - Iljo Keisse
  The cheer from the cabin next door to ours - below the Grenoble velodrome - told us that the result Flanders had been holding its breath for, had ...
More....
Cycling Tours
Top Rides: Suffering in the Black Forest
Sunday, November 15, 2009  1:01:50 PM PT
  An epic day of rain, pain, and suffering is now behind me, and I’ve got the lactic acid as proof after suffering through a super-tough, 3-climb stage ...
More....

Top Rides: The Peri to Fosse Climb
Friday, November 13, 2009  8:38:31 AM PT
  Sometimes my best rides have been those with the least forethought, the least amount of time, the most luck, and just plain looking for the squiggly ...
More....
Comment: What Makes A Professional?
Saturday, November 14, 2009  12:37:26 PM PT
  In a world where money is in short supply, it's encouraging that there are so many pro cyclists in the UK. Or is it? Sponsor of Team Velo ...
More....

Eat To Compete: It’s Soup Time!
Thursday, November 12, 2009  6:25:55 PM PT
  Soup, on many levels, is one of the best things to eat this time of year. It’s warm, it’s a great way to stay full without over-eating (when ...
More....

The Wounded Warrior Project: Soldier Rides 2009!
Wednesday, November 11, 2009  8:41:18 AM PT
  The Wounded Warrior Projects Soldier Ride provides rehabilitative cycling events for severely injured service members. Soldier Ride is not about ...
More....
2009 Tour de France
Vuelta’09 St.21: Greipel’s Day, Valverde’s Vuelta!
Sunday, September 20, 2009  10:58:34 AM PT
  Race report: Alejandro Valverde stayed upright to seal his Vuelta victory – the first Grand Tour win of his career. On such a short stage, ...
More....

Vuelta’09 St.20: Millar Puts Them To The Sword!
Saturday, September 19, 2009  10:56:52 AM PT
  Race Report: Today David Millar won his 5th stage in all his Vuelta’s, he was given one of the swords that Toledo is famous for along with the ...
More....
 
PEZ Talk: BMC Recruit John Murphy
Thursday, November 19, 2009  7:48:44 PM PT
  John Murphy has been promising big things for a long while now. The rider has moved consistently up the ranks over the past six years starting as a ...
More....

PEZ Talk: Six Day Hero Franco Marvulli
Thursday, November 19, 2009  8:13:56 AM PT
  They call it the ‘World Championship of Six Days’ – Munich. And the 2009 winners were – Bruno Risi and Franco Marvulli (Switzerland) from world ...
More....

EuroTrash Thursday!
Thursday, November 19, 2009  7:34:44 AM PT
  It’s still the off season, but BMC are gradually plugging the holes in their 2010 race roster, while Lotto are trying to do the same for their 2010 ...
More....

Battenkill'09: America's Queen Of The Classics
Wednesday, November 18, 2009  1:24:50 AM PT
  America will never be Belgium, but as of 2009, it does have its own hardman Classic. In its first professional edition, the Tour of the Battenkill ...
More....

PEZ Gets Muddy: USGP Weekend In New Jersey
Tuesday, November 17, 2009  11:07:33 AM PT
  Here at PEZ, we adore the mud-filled fun of the cyclocross season, but it's an all too rare event to be able to cover the racing like we do during ...
More....

Toolbox: PowerCranks Winter Training
Tuesday, November 17, 2009  5:57:35 AM PT
  I was at the coffee shop the other day answering questions about those funny gold cranks on my bike (which, during the winter when I am riding my ...
More....

Off-Season PEZ: Vacation In Venice
Monday, November 16, 2009  10:02:46 AM PT
  We love bike racing at PEZ. We really do. Just like our favorite pros though, there's a time at the end of every season for pause, a time for ...
More....
Competitive Cyclist
Crud
Wrench Science
CompuTrainer
ERG Video
 
Wired Bike
V-Gear
V-Gear
 
Powercranks
Defeet
PezCycling Jerseys
cycling jerseys
Cycling Interviews

• Lance Armstrong-1 -2
• Steffen Wesemann
• Floyd Landis
• Max Sciandri
• Jens Voigt
• Andrea Tafi
• Scott Sunderland

Cycling Fitness
cycling training
defeet
 
 
 

 

Copyright © 2009 PezCyclingNews.com - all rights reserved.